Skip to Content

5 Mace Substitutes

Like this recipe? Share it for others!

Mace is a spice derived from the outer covering of the nutmeg seed and is known for its bright, warm flavor with hints of cinnamon and pepper. It’s commonly used in baking, savory dishes, and spice mixes.

Due to its unique taste and sometimes limited availability, finding substitutes that can approximate its flavor profile can be very useful for both home cooks and professional chefs.

Mace and nutmeg on a table.

What is Mace?

Mace is the aril, the bright red webbing that surrounds the nutmeg seed. Once dried, it turns a slightly orange color. Its flavor is similar to nutmeg but sharper and more delicate.

Mace is traditionally used in dishes like pound cakes, pumpkin pies, and savory stews. It also plays a crucial role in many spice blends, such as garam masala and curry powders.

Substitutes for Mace

1. Nutmeg

Nutmeg is the most straightforward substitute for mace, as they come from the same plant. It shares a similar flavor profile, though it is slightly sweeter and less pungent than mace.

Nutmeg can be used in any dish that calls for mace, especially in baking and spice mixes. It’s readily available and less expensive, making it an accessible option for everyday cooking and baking.

2. Allspice

Allspice has a complex flavor that resembles a blend of cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg. It can mimic the warm and spicy notes of mace, making it an effective substitute in both sweet and savory recipes.

Allspice is particularly good in baking, meat marinades, and spice rubs where mace would typically be used. It is widely available and can be a versatile staple in any spice cabinet.

3. Cinnamon

Cinnamon can replace mace in many recipes, providing a warm, sweet flavor that complements a variety of dishes. While it lacks the subtle peppery notes of mace, its sweetness can mimic the gentle warmth that mace provides.

Cinnamon is excellent in desserts, such as cakes and pies, and can also be used in savory dishes like curries and stews. It is one of the most common and affordable spices found globally.

4. Cloves

Cloves offer a strong, pungent flavor that can substitute for mace’s intense warmth. They are more aromatic and have a deeper spice profile, so it is best to use them sparingly to avoid overwhelming a dish.

Cloves work well in spice blends, baked goods, and slow-cooked savory dishes where their robust flavor can meld with other ingredients without dominating.

5. Garam Masala

Garam masala is a spice blend that often includes mace as one of its components. Using garam masala as a substitute allows you to impart a similar set of flavors that mace would contribute to a dish.

This blend is especially useful in Indian cooking, where it can be added to curries, soups, and rice dishes. It’s a handy substitute if you have it in your pantry and are looking to achieve a complex, multi-layered spice profile in your cooking.

How to Incorporate These Substitutes

  • Measurements: Use these substitutes in equal amounts to mace, but adjust according to taste, especially when using stronger spices like cloves.
  • Cooking Tips: Start with a smaller quantity than the recipe calls for if using a stronger substitute, and add more as needed.
  • Recipe Adaptation: Consider the dominant flavors of the dish and select a substitute that will complement the other ingredients without overpowering them.

Final Thoughts

Each substitute offers a different way to capture the essence of mace’s flavor in your dishes. Whether you go for the close relationship of nutmeg, the complex blend of allspice, the sweetness of cinnamon, the intensity of cloves, or the layered flavors of garam masala, you can successfully adapt your recipes to achieve delicious results without mace.

Like this recipe? Share it for others!