Skip to Content

10 Best Sweet Pickle Relish Substitutes

Like this recipe? Share it for others!

Sweet pickle relish is a popular condiment known for its tangy and sweet flavor, commonly used to enhance sandwiches, hot dogs, and salads.

When it’s not available or if you’re exploring different flavors, finding suitable substitutes is key to replicate or complement its unique taste in various dishes.

Sweet pickle relish substitutes in a pantry.

What is Sweet Pickle Relish?

Sweet pickle relish is made from diced pickled cucumbers that are sweetened with sugar and typically flavored with onions, mustard seeds, and other spices.

It’s appreciated for its balance of sweetness and tanginess, adding a distinct flavor and texture to many classic dishes.


1. Dill Pickle Relish

Dill pickle relish, prepared from chopped dill pickles, offers a tangy and slightly sour flavor. It lacks the sweetness of sweet pickle relish but can be an excellent substitute in recipes where a more pronounced tangy flavor is desired, particularly in sandwiches and burgers.

2. Chopped Bread and Butter Pickles

Chopped bread and butter pickles are known for their sweet and tangy flavor and can substitute for sweet pickle relish.

They provide a similar sweetness and a slightly different spice profile, making them suitable for salads, sandwiches, and dressings.

3. Capers

Capers, small pickled flower buds, offer a tangy and briny flavor. They don’t have the sweetness of sweet pickle relish but can be an effective alternative in savory dishes where a burst of acidity is needed, suitable for Mediterranean-inspired dishes and sauces.

4. Chopped Sweet Gherkins

Finely chopped sweet gherkins, which are small sweet pickles, can substitute for sweet pickle relish.

They offer similar sweetness and a crisp texture, making them appropriate for salads, deviled eggs, and as a condiment for hot dogs.

5. Tomato Chutney

Tomato chutney, often a mix of tomatoes, sugar, and vinegar, provides a tangy and sweet flavor that can serve as a substitute for sweet pickle relish.

It adds a unique taste to sandwiches, dips, and can be a flavorful addition to grilled meats.

6. Olive Tapenade

Olive tapenade, consisting of finely chopped olives, capers, and olive oil, offers a savory and slightly briny flavor.

While it lacks the sweetness of sweet pickle relish, it can be an interesting alternative in recipes that require a robust, savory flavor, such as in appetizers and spreads.

7. Giardiniera

Giardiniera, an Italian pickled vegetable mix, can substitute for sweet pickle relish in sandwiches and salads.

It provides a blend of tangy and spicy flavors, including various vegetables like cauliflower, carrots, and peppers, offering a different texture and flavor profile.

8. Corn Relish

Corn relish, made from sweet corn, vinegar, and spices, offers a sweet and tangy flavor. It can be an effective alternative to sweet pickle relish, especially in recipes that pair well with corn’s natural sweetness, such as in barbecues and summer salads.

9. Pickled Onions

Finely chopped pickled onions, with their sharp tangy flavor, can substitute for sweet pickle relish. They add zest to dishes, suitable for tacos, sandwiches, and as a garnish for grilled meats.

10. Cucumber Salad

A cucumber salad, prepared with vinegar, sugar, and dill, can mimic the texture and flavor of sweet pickle relish. This fresh alternative is suitable for sandwiches, burgers, and as a side dish, offering a lighter and fresher taste.

How to Incorporate These Substitutes

When substituting for sweet pickle relish, consider the dish’s flavor profile. Chopped bread and butter pickles or sweet gherkins are good choices for a similar sweetness, while capers, olive tapenade, or pickled onions can add a savory or tangy twist. Adjusting the sweetness or acidity to match the desired taste of your recipe is essential.

Final Thoughts

Although sweet pickle relish has a unique place in culinary applications, these substitutes provide a range of flavors that can either closely match or provide a delightful contrast to its taste.

Each alternative brings unique qualities, allowing for culinary creativity and versatility in a wide array of recipes, ensuring your dishes remain flavorful and enjoyable.

Like this recipe? Share it for others!